Nearly one year after the Space Shuttle Columbia
accident left seven astronauts dead and the U.S. space program stuck in limbo,
NASA is preparing to resume shuttle flights this fall with the knowledge that
the fleet’s days are numbered.
In the months leading up to NASA’s second space
shuttle disaster in 17 years, the agency’s top managers were warming to the idea
of keeping the shuttle flying well into the next decade -- possibly until
2020 or beyond. NASA had scheduled a space shuttle summit for just a few weeks
after Columbia was slated to return from her 28th mission to get working on a
plan for what it would take to keep the fleet flying for many years to
come.
NASA and the nation’s confidence in the aging fleet
changed abruptly when Columbia broke up Feb. 1, 2003 over the western United
States. The Columbia Accident Investigation Board, convened within 48 hours of
the accident, had by August recommended that NASA commit to a thorough
re-certification of the space shuttle fleet before flying it past
2010.
Such an undertaking would not have been cheap.
According to government and industry sources, the White House had
estimated that certifying the shuttle fleet to fly beyond 2010 would cost at
least $3 billion and that keeping it flying would cost about $5 billion a year,
up from the $4 billion NASA spends today.
When U.S. President George W. Bush unveiled a new
space exploration vision for NASA Jan. 14, he pledged the United States to
complete assembly of the international space station by 2010 and then retire the
shuttle fleet.
“The president has given us a different future,”
Michael Kostelnik, NASA’s deputy associate administrator for the space shuttle
and space station programs, said in a Jan. 23 interview.
NASA Administrator Sean O’Keefe told reporters at a
breakfast here Jan. 21 that the agency will meet or exceed all the
recommendations laid down by the Columbia Accident Investigation Board before
shuttle flights resume. He also predicted that once the shuttle is safely flying
again, NASA expects to fly as many as five shuttle missions a year until the end
of the decade.
For now, NASA may have more questions than answers
about how this new future plays out. But some matters are becoming clearer by
the day.
Kostelnik said NASA now has what amounts to a
presidential mandate to return the space shuttle to flight status as soon as
possible and get on with assembly of the space station. To meet these goals on
the timetable set by the president, Kostelnik said, NASA will need to get all
three of its space shuttle orbiters flying again. It will need to continue to
invest in the space shuttle to ensure that it can fly safely until its job is
done. And it will have to achieve a shuttle flight rate comparable to the
schedule NASA sometimes struggled to maintain even before losing
Columbia.
NASA hopes to fly as many as two shuttle missions
before the end of 2004. The earliest would be Sept. 12. If NASA can get that
flight off the ground within a month of that target, Kostelnik said, it would
try for a second shuttle mission in November.
But if NASA misses the launch window that opens Sept.
12 and closes Oct.
10, Kostelnik said the odds of returning to flight in
2004 drop considerably. Because of new restrictions NASA has placed on shuttle
launches at the recommendation of the Columbia Accident Investigation
Board -- such as launching only during daylight hours -- November
offers very few good launch opportunities.
NASA also wants as big a window as possible for the
first flight, so if the program is not ready to go by mid-October, Kostelnik
said, NASA would most likely wait until spring for its return to
flight.
At Kennedy Space Center near Cocoa Beach, Fla., NASA
has two shuttle orbiters -- Atlantis and Discovery -- being prepared
for flight. Kostelnik said the agency would decide by March which orbiter has
the best chance to be cleared for launch this fall.
Whichever orbiter is not picked to fly first,
Kostelnik said, would be kept on track to launch soon after -- and not just
because NASA would like to get two flights in before the end of 2004.
Kostelnik said NASA also wants to have the second
orbiter in position to launch within weeks of the first in case the first crew
finds itself stranded on orbit with a crippled shuttle that cannot be
repaired.
NASA expects to fly the shuttle just two or three
times in its first full year of operations and then ramp up to four or five
flights a year thereafter, Kostelnik said.
NASA’s shuttle manifest is still in flux. But the
agency expects to fly a minimum of eight missions to build the space station out
to a point known as U.S. core complete. Fulfilling the United States’ commitment
to launch the modules and other components being built by its partners would
take an additional 15 shuttle missions.
Kostelnik said NASA is also evaluating whether it
needs to add logistics flights to deliver spare space station hardware, such as
the bulky control momentum gyroscopes, that are too big or too heavy to fit
aboard any vehicle other than the shuttle.
“We are trying to see what options there are to add
in logistics flights in order to put large spares on orbit before we put the
space shuttle fleet down,” he said.
Meanwhile, NASA still has a lot of work to do before
it can launch its first shuttle mission since the Columbia disaster.
An outside panel appointed last year to oversee
NASA’s flight preparations reported Jan. 20 that the shuttle program has a long
way to go to comply with all the conditions the Columbia Accident Investigation
Board imposed on returning to flight.
Writing in its interim report, the Stafford Covey
Task Group said that although NASA is addressing all 29 finding and
recommendations of the CAIB’s final report, progress on many of the
recommendations has been “uneven.”
“As time passes and the interval before the next
scheduled flight diminishes, the enormity of the remaining task looms,” the
report states.
Kostelnik did not dispute the group’s findings. “Our
planning is not complete yet,” he said. “But I think we are peaking, hitting the
crest of things and the sense I’m getting is we will start moving very
aggressively in the next month to month and a half. We have come a long
way.”
Kostelnik said NASA has not finalized its approach to
meeting a number of the key recommendations of the CAIB report, including how to
perform non-destructive testing of the space shuttle’s external fuel tank and
repairing damaged shuttle wings on orbit. NASA is still modeling the danger
posed by the insulating foam the shuttle’s external tank tends to shed during
liftoff, Kostelnik said. Additionally, study of the aerodynamics of a redesigned
fuel tank is still in process, with a mockup of the modified tank not expected
to be ready for wind tunnel testing until summer.
Kostelnik predicted a high level of activity across
the program in the months ahead as NASA settles on the most promising approaches
and moves out quickly to make them happen.
NASA is also going beyond the CAIB recommendations in
some areas. For example, the CAIB requested NASA to come up with a plan prior to
its first flight for establishing a so-called independent technical authority to
guard the space station against what had become the all too frequent practice of
issuing waivers that compromised safety. Kostelnik said NASA not only intends to
have a plan finished by the time it returns to flight, but to have the new
organization up and running.