Metal clouds turn scorching hot exoplanet into the universe's largest mirror

An illustration of the exoplanet LTT9779b as it orbits its star
An illustration of the exoplanet LTT9779b as it orbits its star (Image credit: Ricardo Ramírez Reyes (Universidad de Chile))

Astronomers have discovered the most reflective planet outside the solar system ever seen. The ultra-hot extrasolar planet, or exoplanet, acts like a cosmic mirror because it is covered by reflective clouds of metal. 

The planet, designated LTT9779 b, is located around 264 light-years from Earth and reflects around 80% of the light that shines on it from its parent star. As a comparison to LTT9779 b, Earth reflects just 30% of the light that falls on it from the sun. The ultra-hot LTT9779 b is so reflective that it is the first exoplanet found that gives the solar system's shiniest planet, Venus, a run for its money; Venus has a thick layer of clouds that reflect around 75% of incident sunlight.

The exoplanet is, in turn, almost five times as wide as Earth, meaning it is also the largest cosmic mirror ever discovered. "Imagine a burning world, close to its star, with heavy clouds of metals floating aloft, raining down titanium droplets," research co-author and Diego Portales University astronomer James Jenkins said in a statement.

Related: Good news for the alien life hunt: Buried oceans may be common on icy exoplanets

While LTT9779 b was first discovered by NASA's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS) mission in 2020, the world's highly reflective nature wasn't uncovered until a follow-up investigation by the European Space Agency exoplanet-hunting spacecraft, CHaracterising ExOPlanet Satellite (CHEOPS). LTT9779 b is around the size of the solar system ice giant Neptune, which, coupled with its roasting temperature, class it as an ultra-hot Neptune. 

How LTT9779 b became a Neptune-sized celestial mirror

Initially, the high reflectivity of LTT9779 b, a quality known as 'albedo,' was a mystery to scientists. This is because most planets, other than ice worlds or planets with reflective cloud layers like Venus, have low albedos as a result of their atmospheres or surfaces absorbing starlight, thus preventing it from being reflected back into space. 

LTT9779 b was predicted to have a low albedo because, with a surface temperature of around 3,650 degrees Fahrenheit (2,000 degree Celsius) on the side of the exoplanet that permanently faces its star, it should be too hot to form clouds of water. This high temperature should make LTT9779 b too hot even for even clouds of metals or glass to form. 

"It's a planet that shouldn't exist," says research co-author and Observatory of Côte d'Azur researcher Vivien Parmentier. "We expect planets like this to have their atmosphere blown away by their star, leaving behind bare rock."

The existence of such a planet prompted researchers to explore other theories for how these metal clouds formed. "It was really a puzzle until we realized we should think about this cloud formation in the same way as condensation forming in a bathroom after a hot shower," Parmentier added. "To steam up a bathroom, you can either cool the air until water vapor condenses, or you can keep the hot water running until clouds form because the air is so saturated with vapor that it simply can't hold anymore."

A diagram shows how LTT9779 b acts like a celestial mirror. (Image credit: ESA)

The team thinks that LTT9779 b got its metal clouds and its high albedo when its atmosphere was oversaturated with silicate and metal vaporized by scorching hot temperatures on the planet's permanent dayside.

The reflective nature of LTT9779b isn't its only extraordinary quality, however. The exoplanet is also an example of a planetary type that has eluded astronomers for decades and remains mysterious.

Ultra-hot Neptune is an example of a missing planet type

As an ultra-hot Neptune which orbits so close to its star, LTT9779b is the first in a population of "missing planets" to be discovered. Planets of this size and mass, which orbit close to their parent stars, have been long-absent from the exoplanet catalog, which now contains over 6,000 worlds.

All other planets found so close to their parent star that they orbit them in under a day have been so-called "hot Jupiter" planets with widths around ten times that of Earth, or rocky worlds smaller than twice the size of our planet.

This left an absence of planets with sizes and mass in between these categories at close proximities to their stars. An absence that has come to be known as the "hot-Neptunian desert" by scientists.

With a size just larger than its ice-giant namesake and a 19-hour orbit, LTT9779 b sits firmly in this gap.

An artist's impression of the ultra-hot Neptune LTT 9779b and its parent star, LTT 9779.  (Image credit: Ricardo Ramirez/Universidad de Chile)

The planet's survival in the hot-Neptunian desert so close to its star could share an explanation with its high reflectivity characteristic. 

"We believe these metal clouds help the planet to survive in the hot Neptune desert," research lead author and Marseille Astrophysics Laboratory scientist Sergio Hoyer said. "The clouds reflect light and stop the planet from getting too hot and evaporating. Meanwhile, being highly metallic makes the planet and its atmosphere heavy and harder to blow away."

LTT9779 b is likely to be the focus of extensive study over the coming years, with the exoplanet representing a fine observational target for both the James Webb Space Telescope and the Hubble Space Telescope. This should allow scientists to better understand its atmosphere, clouds, and its other characteristics.

The team’s research is published in the journal Astronomy & Astrophysics.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com.

Robert Lea
Senior Writer

Robert Lea is a science journalist in the U.K. whose articles have been published in Physics World, New Scientist, Astronomy Magazine, All About Space, Newsweek and ZME Science. He also writes about science communication for Elsevier and the European Journal of Physics. Rob holds a bachelor of science degree in physics and astronomy from the U.K.’s Open University. Follow him on Twitter @sciencef1rst.

  • Fang
    Cool! think it can be used for finding more exo-planets like the J.Web systems?
    Reply
  • rod
    "The planet, designated LTT9779 b..."

    Exoplanet properties and info for this planet can be found at these sites.

    http://research.iac.es/proyecto/exoatmospheres/view.php?name=LTT%209779%20b
    http://exoplanet.eu/catalog/ltt_9779_b/
    https://exoplanetarchive.ipac.caltech.edu/overview/LTT%209779%20b#planet_LTT-9779-b_collapsible
    The radius is some 4.72 earth radii size and about 29 earth masses. Its semi-major axis = 0.01679 au, much closer to the host star than Mercury in our solar system. The space.com article states, "As an ultra-hot Neptune which orbits so close to its star, LTT9779b is the first in a population of "missing planets" to be discovered. Planets of this size and mass, which orbit close to their parent stars, have been long-absent from the exoplanet catalog, which now contains over 6,000 worlds."

    Exoplanet studies are becoming more and more interesting :)
    Reply
  • rod
    The exoplanet.eu site shows the host star is 1 solar mass, compare this exoplanet to our solar system configuration. Nothing like LTT 9779 b here. The NASA site reports 0.77 solar mass host,https://exoplanetarchive.ipac.caltech.edu/overview/LTT%209779%20b#star_LTT-9779_collapsible
    Reply
  • PabloMB
    Hi

    I think I have a bigger cosmic mirror: a blackhole. But you should see it from a exotic point of view: the inside.

    The mass of the blackhole bends the spacetime so all of the outgoing lines gets bent incoming. That's what blackholes do. So if you could look upwards from inside a blackhole, I expect you would see something pretty much like a mirror. A mirror not only for light like the ones on earth, but also for energy and matter.

    What size should be this mirror? I'm not sure. I think that the space is bent from the event horizon to the center of the BH, so I guess that deeper is the observer, smaller and closer to him is the mirror-sphere he finds above. If I'm right then the biggest cosmic mirror should be with the minimal possible depth once crossed the event horizon, and the size should be the whole event horizon of the biggest blackhole.

    The "small" detail I have not mentioned is that of course, if you are inside a blackhole and you can see this mirror then you are dead. And if we send a camera, then the camera will not be able to contact us. And it possibly will be difficult to take an action when falling at a relativistic speed.

    Regards - Pablo
    Reply
  • billslugg
    Once inside a black hole event horizon all movement is toward the center, no photons from you could travel out to bounce off of the inside surface of the event horizon so it could function as a mirror. You would not see your image, you would see the outside world's photons coming in.

    And if the black hole was big enough, say several billion solar masses, the tidal forces as you pass through the event horizon would not be noticeable. It would be much later you would get torn apart.
    Reply
  • PabloMB
    Hi Mr. Billslugg
    billslugg said:
    Once inside a black hole event horizon all movement is toward the center, no photons from you could travel out to bounce off of the inside surface of the event horizon so it could function as a mirror. You would not see your image, you would see the outside world's photons coming in.

    And if the black hole was big enough, say several billion solar masses, the tidal forces as you pass through the event horizon would not be noticeable. It would be much later you would get torn apart.
    Thanks for the reply. I have to think and rethink the first phrase, but it's only my homework.
    First post here makes me think and I learn. It looks it's a good forum.
    Thanks. Regards - Pablo
    Reply
  • rod
    LTT9779b semi-major axis = 0.01679 au as previously stated in post #3. There are a bunch of exoplanets now documented with orbits as close or closer than Venus in our solar system, some 49% or more of the data. Most of those exoplanets are large radii size and masses. The exoplanet.eu site currently shows 5460 confirmed, the NASA archive site shows 5470 confirmed. Using the exoplanet.eu site, 2683 orbit closer than Venus in our solar system (a <= 0.73 au), mean mass 2.48 Jupiter masses. The NASA site shows 2693 and mean mass 1.19 Jupiter masses. Radii compared to Earth quite large too, mean near 5.9 earth radii for both list of exoplanets (indicating many exoplanets will have higher surface gravity well and larger escape velocities than Earth). Our solar system arrangement is very different. CHEOPs is finding exoplanets that are large and closer to their parent stars, TESS too. TESS shows 363 confirmed, semimajor axis range 0.00622 au to 0.9 au, mean mass 262.9 earth masses. What do observations like this indicate when looking for ET phoning home or other exoplanets that are claimed to be earthlike with possible life on them or in the habitable zone? IMO, astrobiology and claims of ET phoning home in the Milky Way, have a long way to go to be science.
    Reply
  • billslugg
    A possible reason they are finding lots of large planets close to their stars is because they are easier to detect.
    Reply
  • rod
    IMO, we are rare, the other exoplanet systems are much more common, thus an abundance is being found today in exoplanet studies.

    _Tju7EaSfmMView: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Tju7EaSfmM
    Reply