Was life on Earth sparked by cloud-to-ground lightning strikes?

An illustration shows the landscape of a primordial Earth before life arose as lightning splits the skies
An illustration shows the landscape of a primordial Earth before life arose as lightning splits the skies (Image credit: Robert Lea (created with Canva))

One of the most fundamental questions in science is how life began on Earth. 

Now, scientists may be a step closer to answering that query, finding that lightning on primordial Earth may have been the spark that lit the fuse of life on our planet.

One of the major questions regarding the beginning of life on Earth revolves around how the building blocks for life, such as nitrogen and carbon, emerged on our young planet. The three leading theories include delivery by asteroids and comets that crashed into Earth, emissions from deep-sea vents, and cloud-to-ground lightning strikes. 

According to a team of chemists from Harvard University, that last option is looking mighty likely. 

Related: The building blocks of life can form rapidly around young stars

"Cloud-to-ground lightning strikes could have generated high concentrations of reactive molecules locally, establishing diverse feedstocks for early life to emerge and survive globally," wrote the team in paper a published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS)

 This is far from the first experiment to suggest cloud-to-ground lightning as a potential key to unlocking life on Earth. American chemist and Nobel Prize winner Harold Urey and his research student Stanley Miller performed a similar experiment, appropriately dubbed the Urey-Miller experiment, in 1953. 

They ran an electrical arc as a proxy for lightning through a combination of methane, ammonia, hydrogen, and water — what they thought was the composition of the young Earth's atmosphere — and produced amino acids, which are necessary for the creation of life. 

While the science still holds, we now suspect the young atmosphere is comprised of carbon dioxide and nitrogen. Thus, the Harvard team performed an updated version of the Urey-Miller experiment.

In their lab, the researchers simulated cloud-to-ground lightning strikes in a biosphere that mimicked conditions on a young Earth. They studied the chemical reactions from the strikes, discovering "remarkable yields" of carbon dioxide being reduced into carbon monoxide and formic acid and nitrogen being converted into nitrate, nitrite, and ammonium. 

In other words, the lightning strikes created the right building blocks for life.

So, while lightning didn't necessarily create life, it certainly could have laid the groundwork for life to find a way.

Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com.

Stefanie Waldek
Contributing writer

Space.com contributing writer Stefanie Waldek is a self-taught space nerd and aviation geek who is passionate about all things spaceflight and astronomy. With a background in travel and design journalism, as well as a Bachelor of Arts degree from New York University, she specializes in the budding space tourism industry and Earth-based astrotourism. In her free time, you can find her watching rocket launches or looking up at the stars, wondering what is out there. Learn more about her work at www.stefaniewaldek.com.

  • rod
    This idea about lightening has been discussed in 2023 too.

    Life on Earth quickly became independent from lightning as a nitrogen source, says new study, https://phys.org/news/2023-05-life-earth-quickly-independent-lightning.html
    Other sources for life origin from non-living matter is dust traps in gas clouds.

    https://forums.space.com/threads/the-building-blocks-of-life-can-form-rapidly-around-young-stars.67518/
    Charles Darwin in 1871 postulated the warm little pond but knew that life today would eat non-living matter trying to evolve into life in that warm little pond so you could not see this take place in nature today. Apparently creating that warm little pond involves much catastrophism now when combined with astronomy and lightening strikes.
    Reply
  • billslugg
    An earlier discussion noted that life's precursors might have had a boost from radiation due to elemental decay in the rocks around a seafloor vent. There was no UV down there, no high energy particles like in space.
    Reply