Matter-spewing 'singularities' could eliminate the need for dark energy and dark matter

A new model of the cosmos does away with the universe's two most troubling and mysterious elements, dark energy and dark matter, collectively referred to as the dark universe. Here's the idea.

The new concept replaces the dark universe with a multitude of step-like bursts called "transient temporal singularities" that erupt throughout the entire cosmos.

It's possible, scientists say, that these transient temporal singularities could open to flood the universe with matter and energy, causing the very fabric of space to expand. Those rifts would close so quickly they would remain undetectable, leaving us to see the expansion of the cosmos we credit to dark energy, and the gravitational influence we attribute to dark matter.

"The new model can account for both structure formation and stability, and the key observational properties of the expansion of the universe at large, by enlisting density singularities in time that uniformly affect all space to replace conventional dark matter and dark energy," research author Richard Lieu, a physics professor at The University of Alabama in Huntsville, said in a statement.

The dark universe under pressure

The dark universe is poses such a huge conundrum for scientists because it suggests that only 5% of the matter and energy in the cosmos comprises what we see around us on a day-to-day basis in stars, planets, moons, our bodies — and everything else, really.

In other words, we have no idea what the other 95% of the cosmos is.

Of this enormous slice of the universe's matter and energy budget, dark energy — the placeholder name for the force causing the expansion of the universe to accelerate — accounts for around 70%.

Dark matter, on the other hand, helped the first galaxies gather through its gravitational influence — but it remains effectively invisible because it doesn't interact with light. Yet, dark matter accounts for the remaining around 25% of that matter budget.

The ubiquity of dark matter and dark energy and their importance in our models of cosmic evolution make the dark universe a double mystery that scientists would love to resolve.

Building upon prior research in which he suggested that gravity could exist without the presence of mass, Lieu does away with the need for dark matter and dark energy.

Unlike previous attempts, however, Lieu's model doesn't need an exotic addition to current cosmological models, such as "negative mass" or "negative density," to negate the dark universe.

"Sir Fred Hoyle opposed Big Bang cosmology and postulated a 'steady state' model of the universe in which matter and energy were constantly being created as the universe expands," Lieu explained. "But that hypothesis violates the law of mass-energy conservation."

Lieu instead suggests that via transient temporal singularities, matter and energy can appear and disappear in sudden bursts. This doesn't violate the current conservation laws of physics.

"These singularities are unobservable because they occur rarely in time and are unresolvedly fast, and that could be the reason why dark matter and dark energy have not been found," Lieu added. "The origin of these temporal singularities is unknown – safe to say that the same is true of the moment of the Big Bang itself."

Lieu's model sees these singularities as generating a "negative pressure" with an anti-gravity-like effect serving to push the universe apart at an accelerating rate, just as dark energy is proposed to do.

"An example is the negative pressure exerted by a magnetic field along a field line," Lieu said. "Einstein also postulated negative pressure in his 1917 paper on the Cosmological Constant. When positive mass-energy density is combined with negative pressure, there are some restrictions which ensure the mass-energy density remains positive with respect to any uniformly moving observer, so the negative density assumption is avoided in the new model."

Lieu's ultimate conclusion is that the dark universe and its constituents may not be an omnipresent factor in the cosmos.

"They only appear in brief instances during which the matter and energy do fill the entire universe uniformly, apart from random spatial density variations which grow to form bound structures like galaxies," he continued. "In between which, they are not to be found anywhere.

"The only difference between this work and the standard model is that the temporal singularity occurred only once in the latter, but more than once in the former."

In the future, Lieu intends to try validating his theory by turning to ground-based telescopes to look for "jumps" in redshift — in reference to the stretching of light coming from distant objects as they recede away from us due to the expansion of space.

"The best way to look for the proposed effect is actually to use a large ground-based telescope – like the Keck Observatory [located in Hawaii], or the Isaac Newton Group of Telescopes in La Palma, Spain – to perform deep field observations, the data of which would be ‘sliced’ according to redshift,” he said. “Given sufficient redshift (or, equivalently, time) resolution effected by the redshift slicing, one might just find that the Hubble diagram exhibits jumps in the redshift distance relation, which would be very revealing."

Lieu's research was published on March 21 in the journal Classical and Quantum Gravity.