NASA supercomputer finds billions of comets mimicking the Milky Way's shape: 'The universe seems to like spirals!'
"We found that some comets in the inner Oort cloud form a long-lasting spiral structure."
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/038b8/038b8cd5d19f694724e8f731de95fd7ef637b227" alt="A spiral structure composed of billions of comets"
Spirals are a repeating theme in astronomy, with arguably the most famous example of a swirling armed structure being our home galaxy, the Milky Way. Now, using a powerful NASA supercomputer called "Pleiades," scientists have discovered yet another spiral structure on the edge of our solar system.
The spiral is composed of billions of icy bodies surrounded by a shell of comets called the Oort cloud. Even though the Oort cloud lurks at the edge of our own planetary system and is about 99,000 times as wide as the distance between Earth and the sun, scientists have thus far been in the dark about the structure of the Oort cloud. These new findings, however, give researchers an important clue about the object.
"We found that some comets in the inner Oort cloud found between 1,000 au to 10,000 au, form a long-lasting spiral structure," Luke Dones, study team member and principal scientist at the Southwest Research Institute, told Space.com. (The measurement "au" stands for "astronomical unit," and one au is equal to the distance between Earth and the sun.)
"We were quite surprised," Dones continued. "Spirals are seen in Saturn's rings, disks around young stars and galaxies. The universe seems to like spirals!"
Though insignificant in comparison to the spiral that forms the structure of the Milky Way, Dones and colleagues found that this Oort cloud icy spiral is roughly 15,000 au in length. The spiral runs perpendicular, or at an angle of 90 degrees, to the plane of the Milky Way.
"Only a small fraction of comets in the Oort cloud are in this spiral," Dones added, "but that's still billions of comets."
The team also reached the conclusion that this is not a temporary structure; it is long-lived and persists in the inner Oort cloud to the present day. That means it is still out there to be viewed, but such observations would be no mean feat.
Just chillin' at the edge of the solar system
For context, the Oort cloud is a spherical shell of comets and icy bodies that exist out beyond the orbit of Neptune, which is located around 2.8 billion miles (4.5 billion kilometers) from the sun. This shell is believed to mark the outer boundary of the solar system and is the source of comets that visit the inner solar system, the gas giants Jupiter and Saturn, and the inner rocky planets Mars, Earth, Venus, and Mercury.
The population of the Oort Cloud, often referred to as "trans-Neptunian bodies," is theorized to be composed of material that existed when our solar system's planets were forming around 4.5 billion years ago.
"Our simulations follow the orbits of millions of 'test particles' that represent comets for the age of the solar system, roughly 4.5 billion years," Dones said. "The simulations take so much computing time that we need to use a supercomputer."
Dones added that the visualization team at the American Museum of Natural History (AMNH) first saw the Oort Cloud spiral.
Get the Space.com Newsletter
Breaking space news, the latest updates on rocket launches, skywatching events and more!
Though it wouldn't be impossible to spot this distant spiral with astronomical observations, the task would be extremely tricky. This explains why knowledge of the structure of the Oort cloud has eluded scientists until now.
"Distant objects seen in reflected sunlight are very faint — the brightness decreases as the inverse fourth power of distance," Dones said. "If Earth were placed at the inner edge of the Oort cloud at 1,000 au, it would only be visible in a very large telescope. Comets are much smaller, so they are undetectable at that distance and beyond with optical telescopes."
Thus far, the most reliable way to study comets from the Oort cloud is to catch them when their elongated orbits bring them into the inner solar system. Here, they are heated by the sun and become active, expressing gas and dust that create a surrounding halo and a characteristic tail.
Ironically, comets in this inner Oort Cloud spiral may avoid investigations conducted this way by resisting the journey into the inner solar system.
"Comets in the outer Oort cloud are more likely to enter the solar system's planetary region and become observable because they are held less strongly by the sun's gravity than comets closer in the inner cloud, and so are easier perturbed by passing stars," Dones said. "The comets in thein the inner Oort cloud, especially those in the spiral, are less likely to become observable."
That doesn't mean Dones has given up hope of seeing this comet spiral via astronomical data.
"We still rely on comets that enter the planetary region to infer the population of comets that we can't observe directly, but the distance from the sun at which comets are being discovered is increasing steadily," Dones said. "Some comets are active between the orbits of Uranus and Neptune."
Dones explained that one of the best bets to see this Oort spiral might be the Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST), a 10-year-long planned program for the Vera Rubin Observatory, which is scheduled to begin later this year.
"LSST should detect large comets at distances beyond the orbit of Neptune, although still well within 1,000 times the distance between Earth and the sun," Dones said. "The spiral might also be detected by looking for thermal emission by dust at far-infrared/sub-millimeter wavelengths in data whose main focus is to study the Cosmic Microwave Background radiation."
The team's research is available in a pre-peer-reviewed paper on the repository site arXiv.
Join our Space Forums to keep talking space on the latest missions, night sky and more! And if you have a news tip, correction or comment, let us know at: community@space.com.
Robert Lea is a science journalist in the U.K. whose articles have been published in Physics World, New Scientist, Astronomy Magazine, All About Space, Newsweek and ZME Science. He also writes about science communication for Elsevier and the European Journal of Physics. Rob holds a bachelor of science degree in physics and astronomy from the U.K.’s Open University. Follow him on Twitter @sciencef1rst.
-
Classical Motion How many turns per orbit does that spiral have. How many turns per orbit do the spirals of Saturn rings have? And why can’t we find photos of them? They use to be easy to pull up.Reply
Helix. Not spiral. All planets and moons are one turn helix orbits. 90 degrees to their orbit.
A spiral moves in and out, a helix only changes direction.
I saw this years ago of Io’s orbital path thru it’s debris field. Can’t find those photos either. A easily seen one turn helical orbit. The track of an orbit. Just like a cloud chamber. Only closed in an orbit.
The directional acceleration vectors of this dynamic is much different than an elliptical orbit.
We need new gravity equations. And new simulations. And perhaps a new concept of a “stable” orbit.
Just an observation. -
Western Sage
To this layman, it seems the spiral structure is very similar to eddies that form on edges and against obstacles in moving water and gas. Perhaps someone knowledgable in fluid or aero dynamics can help us understand this feature.Admin said:Astronomers have discovered that billions of comets in an icy shell around the solar system called the Oort Cloud mimic the spiral structure of the Milky Way.
NASA supercomputer finds billions of comets mimicking the Milky Way's shape: 'The universe seems to like spirals! : Read more -
ARTGLICK Doesn't the existence of this spiral suggest a large mass object at the center? Much like a spiral galaxy, has anyone suggested that the object could be a black hole, in this case obviously a intermediate sized one?Reply
How about an Oort version of the fabled Kuiper object Planet 9?
This article misses the point by not offering prevailing conjectures of how this structure formed. -
George² For context, the Oort cloud is a spherical shell of comets and icy bodies that exist out beyond the orbit of Neptune,
after the Kuiper belt.
I just finished the sentence so there was no information gap. -
billslugg They didn't "discover" anything, they predicted something. They did a simulation and got a spiral in the computer. They will now figure out a way to verify it by observation. The problem is how small the bodies are, how dark they are and how far away they are. They might be mapped by occultation, but that's about it.Reply -
bolide
That's my understanding. This spiral has not been seen as yet in any observational data. They created a computer simulation of the Oort cloud, and found a spiral in the simulation.billslugg said:They didn't "discover" anything, they predicted something. They did a simulation and got a spiral in the computer. They will now figure out a way to verify it by observation. The problem is how small the bodies are, how dark they are and how far away they are. They might be mapped by occultation, but that's about it. -
Helio Yes, even an object the size of Jupiter at about 10,000 AU is too dim for even the HST. The JWST can see “warm” objects ar greater distances in IR, but small objects are cold.Reply -
JustThinkAboutIt Why is the Oort Cloud only located on one side of the solar system? Why is there a spiral pattern emerging? Uhhh, because everything in our Solar System is being dragged by the Sun, we do not revolve around the sun, from our perspective on Earth we do, but in actuality we are Spiraling behind the Sun as it moves through the cosmos. Problem solved, I don't need a Nobel prize. Use your heads people , jeez, I knew exactly what was happening as soon as I started reading this article.Reply
Also going to Mars is a one way trip, because we do not possess the technology to make the return trip, ships would need to move faster than the sun moving through space to "catch back up" with Earth. -
COLGeek
I wouldn't hold my breath on that prize. Your theory is simply wrong.JustThinkAboutIt said:Why is the Oort Cloud only located on one side of the solar system? Why is there a spiral pattern emerging? Uhhh, because everything in our Solar System is being dragged by the Sun, we do not revolve around the sun, from our perspective on Earth we do, but in actuality we are Spiraling behind the Sun as it moves through the cosmos. Problem solved, I don't need a Nobel prize. Use your heads people , jeez, I knew exactly what was happening as soon as I started reading this article.
Also going to Mars is a one way trip, because we do not possess the technology to make the return trip, ships would need to move faster than the sun moving through space to "catch back up" with Earth. -
Classical Motion One can find a lot of artist’s renditions of the outer solar system. From what I’ve read, most of our system lies beyond Pluto’s orbit. I’m not sure what they base those concepts on, perhaps radar. I don’t think many can be spotted with optics. Maybe lots of small lines show up. I haven’t seen any photos. Anyhow from what they paint there are thousands if not millions of “icy” objects out there. It looks dense. They appear to emphasize it.Reply
How much water is that? Or how much water was that? And supposedly, lots of debris from our formation. Maybe some of it is Mar’s water.
Was/is that region a resource cabinet, or a garbage dump? Does the solar wind accelerate thru it too? Or maybe decelerated and accumulate there?
From what I’ve read we really don’t know much about it. From what little entry into it, it seems to be pretty sparse. Of course density is relative.
I would rather see a survey of that region more than a man Mars trip. But that’s just me.
We would feel pretty silly if we found a lost planet remains and/or civilization out there. Even worse a derelict alien craft/probe.
We haven’t seen the backyard.
We have found that life can live with just heat and not light. A heated dark planet might have a different kind of life tree. I doubt they are there now, but maybe in the past.